Friday, 19 July 2024

Change is the only Constant Thing in the Process of Learning Chinese. By Serene Zawaydeh. July 19, 2024

 

Change is the only Constant Thing in the Process of Learning Chinese.  By Serene Zawaydeh. July 19, 2024

I wrote several Blogs about the process of learning Chinese. Please scroll down for links.

It is strange to see articles that compare testing proficiency in Chinese language to other European language tests. Learning Chinese is totally different. This is another article that I am writing, while studying for HSK5. I have not completed this level yet, but I have taken courses that include words from higher levels. Furthermore, the exercises in the books and the workbooks, include words that are not in the list of new words in each chapter. The student is expected to do the research needed to solve these questions. Watching other content and videos, a lot of words would pop up from other levels, whether HSK 6 or HSK 7-9. Taking classes with native speakers and studying with books other than HSK5 books, one encounters words from higher levels too. It seems to be inaccurate to say that a student studying HSK5 only knows 2500 words.

One has to figure out ways to learn new words, and to do exercises to practice words that were learnt. The learning process needs to be updated, as the amount of information that needs to be processed keeps increasing beyond HSK4. As new exams are expected to introduce a higher number of words starting from HSK1, the new students learning Chinese might find it difficult to handle the amount of information they are expected to know right from the beginning.

I would like to share some notes about the ongoing learning process. This might provide information about why this language is different than other languages, if someone who does not know any Chinese reads this article. It might spark interest in learning the language. It might also provide some insights for new learners, or an indication of the amount of effort needed for this process. I did not come across articles by others who share details of their learning experience, and the kind of process they went through to reach advanced levels in Chinese.

Writing Chinese characters on a paper using a pencil should start at HSK1. The speed of writing increases over time. Writing can start by writing the single character many times; moving to writing sentences, and writing the whole text for the lesson that needs to be learnt, along with all the new words. Standardized lined paper with squares for writing Chinese characters should be used.

Typing Chinese characters is an important part of the learning process. Typing the Characters requires prior knowledge of the needed character, how it is written, and its pinyin.

Several exercises can be done while typing.

1)     Starting with a word (shāng); and knowing how it is actually pronounced compared to other words (shāng), (chǎng), (chéng).

2)     The word can be combined with another character to give it another meaning, and learning a new word while checking meanings. Starting with the word above (shāng), it is found in other words, such as (shāng)() business,  (shāng)()  to negotiate

() can be used in other words. Such as:

(zuò)() homework , ()():  task

3)     Typing down words encountered that have a similar sound, regardless of the pinyin, then adding the pinyin on top of each character, to know the differences.

Shi: (shí) (shì) (shí) (shì) (shī) (shì) (shī) (shí) (shì) (shì) (shí) (shī) (shì) (shì) (shǐ) (shí)(shi) (shì), (shí) (shì) (shǐ) 湿(shī), (shī)使(shǐ) , (shì) (shī) (shì)(shì)

Sorting the words by tone:

First tone: (shī), (shī), (shī), 湿(shī),  (shī), (shī)

Second tone: (shí)(shí)(shí)(shí)(shí)(shí)

Third tone: (shǐ), (shǐ), 使(shǐ)

Fourth tone: (shì)(shì)(shì)(shì), (shì)(shì), (shì)(shì), (shì), (shì), (shì)

Neutral: (shi)

Each one of these words, can be combined with other characters, to give new meanings. For example:

()(shi) story                                         (shì)() accident

(shī)() to lose                                      (shī)(bài) to lose

(yōu)(shì)      advantage                          ()(shì)      tendency             ()(shì)dead

(shí)(shī) implement                               (cuò)(shī) measure                  

(shí)(zài) actually                                    (zuò)(shì)     

In order to get a specific character, one would have to type the word that has this character.  For example, to get  (shì), one has to type (shì)(jiè) which means world. To get (shì), one should write 办公室 which  means office.

The words can be made of one character, two, three characters. Idioms made of 4 characters are encountered primarily in advanced levels, and are interesting to learn at any level. This is a way to increase exposure to new vocabulary while learning stories about idioms.  

 4)     Another exercise for typing, it to write words that have something in common, learning new vocabulary, and noticing the differences between words.

(shū) to lose, to transport, to donate
(tōu) to steal. In order to get this word, need to type (xiǎo)(tōu) which means thief.
()cheerful, as in 愉快 pleasant, which comes in to (zhōu)()()(kuài) Have a nice weekend!

When new words pop up, one can guess the what the word could be. For example, () means loose garment. Seeing this word for the first time, it looked like words already learnt that are related to clothes. Such as: ()(zi) trousers(chèn)(shān) shirt(qún)(zi) skirt.

5)     Words that have similar sounds, and have similarities in writing. This helps with guessing how new words can be pronounced, as well as the possibility of learning new words 

(gāo) tall, high, and 高兴 happy, which can be 高高兴兴 in a good mood

(gǎo) to do, to make, to take care of. The radical is the hand, and is found in verbs or actions.

For example: to find; which means to support. While the word that is learnt is which means low.

 稿gǎo as in 稿gǎozhǐ which is the standardized writing paper with squares or lines. The word that is already learnt is which means paper.

6)     In Chinese, two words can be combined to give a new meaning. If the person did not see this combination of words previously, and did not learn it previously, or if they know only one meaning for this word, they would not understand the meaning of the combination of the two words.


means hand.
Adding them together, gives the word
手表,means watch.

 biǎo: can refer to family relationship via females, for example 表妹 means younger female cousin. Other meanings for are: to show (one's opinion)

手表: a watch which is a noun.

表示 to express ; 发表to publish are verbs.

The same word in Chinese can be a verb or a noun.


工作 means to work, and also means job. Following are other words that are combined with it

工作人员 staff member
工作日means workday
工作时间working hours
工作服 working clothes
工作委员会 working committee

工作单位 work unit

工作组 work team

教育工作者 educator

社会工作 social work

新闻工作者 journalist

工作量 workload

While doing exercises in workbooks associated with the HSK5 books, it is noticed that there a lot of new words that pop up in the exercises, that were not in the list of new words in the chapter being studied. Although there is a list of words for HSK5, there are a lot more new words in the workbooks that are might not be listed as new words, but one should be familiar with them. Solving the questions in the textbook and the workbook is needed.

The learning process using different sources, provides exposure to more topics that need to be learnt. The words appear in a different order, rather than just following the words one chapter at a time.  One can also learn material from higher levels.

In addition to writing down the lesson and the new words; typing the text for the given lesson and adding the pinyin to words to know the specific tone; translating the text can be done as part of the preparation for new lessons. A paragraph is written without spaces between words. One is supposed to know whether this character should be read on its own, or combined with the following character or two, or if four characters should be read together.  Having the right tones and knowing which characters are read together as one word is needed. Reading the text out loud many times, with the right tones being shown, will help with getting the correct tones for the words. The reading speed gets better with repetition.

As the text gets longer, classes for learning the material provide more information in a shorter period of time. Using tools that can provide a quicker method for capturing characters can be useful. However, the results obtained automatically should be revised, as sometimes the characters are incorrectly recognized. The automatic translation can also provide indications on errors in typing or automatic character recognition.  It should be noted that one word can have more than one meaning. Looking at the translation is useful for capturing these new meanings, which could be totally unrelated to given text.

There is a lot of information that needs to be learnt in one sentence, or a paragraph. It is not just the pinyin that needs to be known or the meaning of one word. Grammar points are explained in Chinese. There are textbooks that have the meanings of the words explained in Chinese language. The examples are given in Chinese and contain new words as well.

HSK Words

The following graph from Chinese Zero to Hero shows the words that should be learnt in different levels, starting with HSK1, up to HSK6. There is one exam for HSK 7-9, which has a total of 11,000 word.

https://www.chinesezerotohero.com/hsk-word-vis/ 

Language Player

The complexity of learning Chinese increases with higher levels. One should watch more videos, and should look at more content, and should not only rely on just reading the given text in a chapter.  

Language Player is an extremely useful tool that I have purchased, and I use it every day while learning Chinese. It provides a huge library of videos, songs, resources not only for learning Chinese, but for learning over 200 other languages.  It provides videos for each word, showing where the word was spoken. It provides comparisons of words, and examples of sentences that have these words.

One of the amazing features that are really great about Language Player’s Dictionary, is “Let ChatGPT Explain”. This is extremely helpful, as it provides detailed explanation of the meaning of the word in the specific text. If the word is part of a grammar point and is usually associated with another word, that will also be highlighted. Such cases might not be noticed previously. Getting detailed explanation from ChatGPT, shows the meaning of the word in the given text, providing a much clearer understanding of the given text.

Other Blogs I wrote

 

Friday, 28 June 2024

Making up Stories using Chinese Characters. 看汉字写小故事!by Serene Zawaydeh, June 29, 2024

Making up Stories using Chinese Characters. 看汉字写小故事!
by Serene Zawaydeh. June 29, 2024

The objective of the stories made up in this Blog, is to practice writing Chinese, using a combination of words, characters and radicals. After coming across more and more Chinese words, it becomes interesting to learn more words, and to look into the details of the characters and radicals that are used in different words, as well as words that sound similar but are written differently. 

The driver of the events in the stories below are 汉字 shapes and similarities. The events are not real, and the stories are just to practice writing using Chinese words. There is no purpose out of writing the story, other than just using a set of selected words. The events of the story itself are not what is meant to be interesting, but rather how the words are written in Simplified Chinese. Keep the text below without translation at least the first time, to notice how the characters are written. You can scroll down to the end of the article, to see a list of words that was made before making up the stories, and was referred to, to make up events! 

我想写下来一个故事,关于文字, 因为我想汉字看起来很有意思。

哦!我饿了。我去外面。在外面有很多树,因为我在森林。在田上到处有绿色的叶子。我看不清楚,因为有点儿雾。我找到一个非常漂亮的蝴蝶,它飞来飞去,旁边那个很平静的河。我拿我的背包, 喝水。 那天有很多人,不知道为什么那么多人在森林里做什么。我往前走。我发现有一对男人和女人, 似乎是他们的婚礼。可能是世界上最漂亮的婚礼。有一辆车, 这很奇怪, 因为上面画的很多鱼。 我闻一下很好的味道。有一个男人, 力量很大。我想, 可能他们一定是福 人。我走一走,看到一个很大的广告。上面写的:谢谢你们大家参加我们特别重要的一天。我们知道可能有几个人,情况不太好。所以, 我们决定请大家免费的吃,喝饮料。你只需要祝福我们生活幸福健康。大家都感觉愉快, 没有郁闷的人。都心情非常好。父母和亲人都觉得对方很恩爱, 互相理解。女士觉得男士是她永远的理想伴侣。没有人会忘记这么好的天。所有的人感到他们赢了, 因为他们都回家,过了最好的时刻。他们拍很多照片, 然后他们排队和新婚夫妇合影。我盯着这个婚礼的细节。 他们选择一个很好的节日来开始未来的日子。

我在网上找到一个宾馆。我进入卧室,感到很冷,外面刮大风。我累死了。第二天早上,睡觉的时候, 我被蚊子吵醒了。我感觉不舒服,可能是做了噩梦。一个巨大的鳄鱼来吃我。天气不好。 我带我的雨伞,因为下雨了,有雷电。我怕闪电。我没想到居然很快白天就会这么热。 在墙上,有一个很好看的画,上面有一群鸟,鸽子。我决定去吃鸡蛋,然后去吃烤鸭。

第三天,我去爬山的时候,遇到了一只有点儿胖的动物。我不知道是什么种的。我问一下。别人说,可能是一个熊猫, 因为它吃竹。

在我的背包,有几本书,因为还要学习几节课。我的目标就是可以用最有意思的汉字。那个背包有点儿重,因为我带来我最重要的书。我买了一些关于汉语的书, 为了练习阅读, 就是从很有名的卖家买的。 这让我一直忙于阅读和学习。 我一直想认识到更多的汉字。 不会感到无聊。

 在机场,我等待飞机,我阅读关于城市和旅游景点的书籍。我一边喝茶,一边查看各种广告。我了解到有一些很好的超市和饭店。我决定去尝试一些新菜, 花了几分钟,赶紧找到我的登机牌。 我看一下有一个宝贝在哭。 我在超市里发现了一些使用最新科技的机器, 但是我不想在最后一天花这么多钱。觉得旅游时不需要穿这么贵的衣服。 正式的衣服适合在其他活动中穿。 

在路上,我发现有一位官员,可能是因为附近有政府大楼。我用我的手机来写短信的时候, 找到卖甜品的超市。 我进来,发现他们卖的蛋糕是用蜜而不是用糖做的, 对身体有好处, 这让我高兴得不得了。

 

https://wordcloud.online/zh

Following are the characters that were basis for making up this story. For sure, many more stories can be made up with the words. Some characters might have been left out and not used in the stories. Reading the translation of the bullet points below, does not make sense, as each line just has some characters selected for their shape or sound. 

·    
一二三十品哭器鳄噩梦回墙
·        门问闻闭闷心才吻勿耳闪电
·        飞非费肥菲
·        福夫妇付府
·        田天
·        男历力量
·        日重睡觉决定觉得
·        虫蝴蝶蚊子蜜蛋糕高兴
·        月文字世占站
·        意思思想 木目目标表示
·        人广时间女裤子车
·        入人众两一辆车两从
·        河可叮盯听
·        课科料棵颗页说况
·        我饿哦钱钱
·        写与鱼于喝渴望王吂忙赢
·        木森林
·        中种
·        雨雪山雷
·        宾馆官
·        甜天田
·        那拿
·        鸟鸡蛋鸽子烤鸭天鹅

ChatGPT checked the paragraphs in Chinese and fixed some sentences. 

If you are a Native speaker, or you studied Chinese, and your Chinese is by far better than mine, will be happy to get your feedback on how the sentences could be improved. I am still in the process of learning HSK5.

 Check out other Blogs I wrote about learning Chinese 


  • 我的汉语学习方式做完HSK四之后 2023213
  • Learning Chinese: What kind of effort is needed to complete HSK4, and what is it like to study higher levels?    2023 213
  • What does the process of learning Mandarin Chinese look like? Some tips for new learners.”   2022 20 
  • The Ongoing Process of Learning Chinese, HSK5.  2024 10
  • Examples of Simplified Chinese. There is no end to learning 学无止境2024 22 
  • Change is the only Constant Thing in the Process of Learning Chinese. 2024 7 19 
  • Tips for Practicing Writing Chinese Characters. 2024910
  • What if… Higher Levels of HSK Chinese Tests could be Redesigned? 20244
  • Making up Stories using Chinese Characters. 看汉字写小故事!2024 629 
  • Lost Bag Story, Handwritten in Chinese; 2023 16 
  • Tuesday, 2 April 2024

    What if… Higher Levels of HSK Chinese Tests could be Redesigned? By Serene Zawaydeh, April 2, 2024

     

    What if… Higher Levels of HSK Chinese Tests could be Redesigned in some other way, other than the proposed new structure for HSK exams? By Serene Zawaydeh, April 3 2024

    Modified on December 9, 2025

    This Blog follows LinkedIn communication with Khanji School, creators of Chinesimple mobile app, about restructuring HSK exams. I have been using this app since HSK1, and used it extensively in every exam, HSK1, HSK2, HSK3, HSK4, and now I am using it while studying for HSK5. It is an excellent tool for practicing learning Chinese words and sentences in an interactive way.  Chinesimple has introduced translations to different languages, and Arabic is a new addition. The Arabic content currently available was generated by AI. I reviewed the AI's Arabic translation for the interface. Please scroll to the end for some screen shots of the conversation. 

    With the existing HSK 2.0 structure of HSK exams, learning Chinese becomes more challenging at HSK5. The number of words doubles from 1200 in HSK4, to 2500 in HSK5 to 5000 in HSK6. However, the actual vocabulary that the student should be able to understand, seems to be higher than 2500 in HSK5. While trying to solve questions, the student encounters new words in the sentences in questions, as well as explanations of grammar points. But then, who is counting words?

    Following are some suggestions about restructuring HSK exams at higher levels, in case some educators might be interested in some feedback from someone learning the language as a fifth language, outside the scope of university studies. 

    • Keeping HSK1 to HSK3 content the same.  
    Currently, there are plans to change the HSK exams, adding new words from HSK1, making it comparable to the existing HSK3. This means that learning Chinese will become more difficult starting from HSK1, and the student might not be able even to complete one level. Some students quit studying after level 2 or 3.
    • Adding new exams for higher levels, without doubling the number of words from one level to the other, regardless of the number of exams needed to reach native speaker fluency level. 

    •  The number of new words required from each level could be fixed, for example, 600 new words in each level.

    ·       Dividing the material of HSK5 and HSK6.

    For example, having one exam for HSK5 上, and another exam for HSK5 下。 Taking into consideration that HSK5 takes more than one year on its own. So having an exam after one year of studying for HSK5 without the need to create new material for HSK5. As the number of words is 2500, it could be even divided into 4 levels, and the student could take tests after finishing each quarter of the current material. If the student learns the material well, and gets a good grade, they can move on to the following stage with steady steps.

    ·        Adding new HSKK speaking exams. Currently there are just three levels for HSK 口语。 The first exam is done with HSK3, the second exam with HSK4, and the third exam with HSK5. Some students do the intermediate speaking exam with HSK5, and could get a better grade, as they could use more vocabulary from HSK5, to explain ideas in easy pictures that require HSK4 knowledge. As for using the limited vocabulary learnt in HSK4, which is 1200 words, that would allow the student to pass the exam and could get some extra point above the passing note. This is for students who do not have access to native Chinese speakers on a daily basis, which is the case for someone living in China.

    ·        The current 高级speaking test includes repeating a paragraph after listening to it only once. This seems to be difficult even for someone listening to a paragraph in their own native language. It would be interesting to know details about grades of people who have obtained an excellent score in this part of the exam, and specifically people who do not live in an environment where people speak Chinese on a daily basis.  There needs to be some kind of fair assessment for the content based on what students were requested to learn.

    ·       Currently, if a student takes higher level language courses with native speakers, the teacher would be using words outside the scope of HSK5, as native speakers does not have the words sorted into categories in their mind. The student encounters more vocabulary while trying to learn HSK5 material. The student is also expected to listen to music, watch TV and news, which bring about much more vocabulary in every sentence.

    ·        In addition to the speed at which the question is given, only once, many Chinese words have similar pronunciation to words previously learnt. This is why it is essential to know how the word is written, to know the meaning of the word and to be able to repeat the sentences. 

          Chinese language learning should not be compared to other languages, as there are thousands of characters, and not a specific set of alphabets. When reading a new book, if one did not see the word previously, and did not learn its meaning, they will not be able to pronounce it and read it properly. This is different than reading a book for the fun of reading, as one would spend their time trying to figure out the meanings of so many words. There are also words that are used formally in writing, and words that are used in spoken Chinese. This is why learning Chinese means continuously looking up new words that were not encountered. 

          New words sound like words previously encountered, and there isn't one specific sound for one unique word, and a lot of words sound similar. When given a specific word in English, you would be able to read it in one way. There is only one word that is written this way, and it gives a specific meaning. Imagine learning a new word in English, only to find that many words can be pronounced this way as you keep learning new vocabulary. This is what learning Chinese is like. 

     

    One part can be used to make several words, when combined with other parts. Example: 

    植物 plant ,动物  animal 

    Restructuring HSK exams at higher levels, could be for the benefit of expanding knowledge of Chinese language, beyond the scope of studying inside China. Comparing Chinese language tests to tests of European language tests, is irrelevant, and will only make it more difficult for new students to learn the language.  

    Chinese is an interesting language to learn, and students need to be able to continue studying it at higher levels, without spending over a year for one higher level, while studying in their home country.  Studying Chinese at higher levels, requires finding new ways to learn, in order to be able to acquire the big amounts of information. The student needs to continuously adapt the method of learning at higher levels, and needs to find out if there are new sources being developed, and who might be sharing their knowledge, from students who already achieved great results, and learn from them if they step into the teacher's role, during their studies.

    The ability of Chinese kids to pick the language from their parents and teachers, should not be a basis of comparison, when comparing adult students of other nationalities who speak other languages.

    It should also be taken into consideration that studying Chinese in China, and being surrounded by Chinese speakers on a daily basis, is unlike studying outside China, in an environment that does not have Chinese speakers on a daily basis.

    Studying in China accelerates the student’s learning experience. Meanwhile, it is not obvious, how the learning process is done, for someone living outside China. Nevertheless, this does not mean that the only way for a student to learn the language is in China. Students should be given the opportunity to keep progressing in their learning experience, and to have a fair assessment at higher levels, in order for them to continue their learning journey in their home country using online resources and apps, if they do not have the opportunity to study in China.

    Students who are interested in learning the language, should be to have their own path of continuous education, regardless of age limitations, and should be able to assume new jobs, with organizations that do not have age limitations. Their interest in learning Chinese could attract new students within their network of different age groups, to study the language.  They will also know of obstacles that are faced while learning the language; can contribute to the process of learning the language while sharing their learning experience; in addition to using the material that is created by new teachers within their society, in the local language. This is of great use at higher more complicated levels.

    Previously, my Chinese instructors were all native speakers. However, after taking classes with    Chinese language teachers of Arabic origin, who learned Chinese, and went on scholarships, it    turned out that learning Chinese with Arabic translation is very helpful. While English has been the intermediate language while learning Chinese, Arabic resources and books provide direct        translation from Chinese into Arabic, and make it possible to directly understand the meaning. I    have also been reading books with translation from Chinese into Arabic, figuring out the meanings of new words translated into Arabic. 

    Chinese is learnt one word at a time. 

    The student is required to watch movies and songs while studying for higher level. However, there is a lot of information to be grasped. Translation of the lyrics of the song, along with the word in Chinese, and the pinyin, the meaning in English, all being displayed along with the video of the song. Pop up questions also appear in the middle of videos, in an application like Language Player. It is interesting to listen to Chinese songs, and they have nice meanings. However, words that are just seen without being written down, might be recognized when seen the next time, but need more effort to be understood, including writing down the word several times, and then it has to appear several times in sentences, to be eventually remembered. So learning thousands of new words, is very time consuming. This is why having more higher level exams would be better for the learners than having one exam that could need more than two years of studying, while the validity of the exams is two years. It should also be taken into consideration that Chinese learning will take years, to reach the high levels.

    Chinese native speakers spend 12 years learning the language at school. So this could be the period of time needed to achieve full native proficiency. So why are there just 6 levels, and why would the foreign students be expected to have such big jumps to level 5, and 6? Is that to make it easier to filter out the students at level 6? The new additional exam which classifies the student into levels 7 to 9, contains 11,092 words. There might not be a need for that, but it would be great if there are more assessments, than what is available now.

    HSK 3.0

    Information about the structure of the new HSK 3.0 exams was announced in November 2025. The new structure categorizes HSK1 to 3 as Elementary level with writing being required from the beginning; HSK 4, 5, and 6 are now Intermediate level; while HSK 7-9 is the Advanced level. 

    This is a significant change, as previously, HSK6 was considered Advanced with around 5400 words. Level 9 requires 11,092 words.

    The Advanced Levels 7-9, are for university students (Master's/ PhD) and Chinese majors, for assessing higher-level application.  

    Technology and AI are being integrated into the test design, proctoring, scoring. 

    AI is already being used by students for learning Chinese.  

    Implementation of the new exams will make it difficult for the students learing HSK1. It would not come as a surprise if the numbers of students learning Chinese decline in the future. 


    Using ChatGPT while Studying Chinese
    Technology is helpful for remotely learning Chinese. Making sentences is an important part of improving the students’ ability to communicate their ideas.  However, these sentences need to be adjusted, and corrected by someone who knows the language. This is where ChatGPT can be a useful tool.

    In the following example, I provided ChatGPT with several words that have the sound Zhong, regardless of the tones, and asked it to make a sentence, add the pinyin, and asked for an idiom for the sentence. Here are the results:

    Me: Can you make a sentence with these words?! 中, 钟,种, 忠, 仲, 重, 终, 众,盅,肿,衷

    ChatGPT: 

    在公园里,钟声敲响,忠实的仲友中,有一种重要的衷心,最终凝聚成了众人的力量。 

    Me: What does it mean?

    ChatGPT: The sentence can be translated as:

    "In the park, the bell rings, among loyal friends, there is a kind of important sincerity, which eventually gathers the strength of the crowd."

    It depicts a scene where the ringing of a bell in the park brings together loyal friends, emphasizing the importance of sincerity and unity, which eventually becomes a collective strength

    Me: can you add the pinyin?

    ChatGPT: Certainly! Here's the sentence with Pinyin:

    Zài gōngyuán lǐ, zhōngshēng qiāo xiǎng, zhōngshí de zhòng yǒu zhōng, yǒu yī zhǒng zhòngyào de zhōng xīn, zuìzhōng níngjù chéngle zhòng rén de lìliàng.

     Me: Is there an idiom that can be used for this sentence?

    Chat GPT:
    Yes, there is an idiom that fits well with the theme of unity and strength depicted in the sentence:
    "众志成城" (zhòng zhì chéng chéng). This idiom literally translates to "when the will of the masses converges, a fortress is formed" and figuratively means "unity is strength" or "many hands make light work." It perfectly captures the idea of collective effort and strength depicted in the sentence.


       
    The collective strength of current students who are learning Chinese, and who have reached HSK5 and beyond, while learning in their home country, can be useful for future learners, who still have not started learning the language, and who will be faced with bigger hurdles starting from HSK Level 1, if the new HSK system is implemented. It is actually strange that the decision to change the HSK structure, should be based on a comparison of Chinese to European languages, as there is by no way any comparison between Chinese and European language. Why would the decision be made to go ahead and implement such a change to exams, which would not be for the best interest of foreign Chinese language learners?
    The objective of the first few levels, is to determine whether the student is interested in the language, and can make a serious effort to study the language, and obtain excellent scores. If studying HSK1 is made too difficult, students will have to drop out, and will not be able to enjoy the learning experience. 
         
    If students drop out after HSK4, and no body voices their opinion about the exponential level of difficulty, the new exams will be implemented, and will not be for the benefit of future learners from different countries and different educational backgrounds. 

    Another question to bring up, is regarding translation of text in future HSK exams. If translation is required, which language should the text be translated to? The assumption should not be that all students can translate from Chinese to English, as there are other languages other than English. Students who are learning Chinese are also learning English, but it is not their native language. The question would be whether the student can translate to their native language, which is Arabic. And if it is Arabic, then there are different dialects. Would a translation be accepted if text was translated into Jordanian accent, or does it have to be translation into Modern Standard Arabic? The objective of the test is to test understanding, and there are many languages to which the translation can be made and it can be understood in different languages. This would make scoring of the tests more troublesome, and would require knowledge of Chinese native speakers, of other international languages and dialects, in case dialects would be possible. This is why translation tests should be separate, and could be specific to students who are taking translation courses. Questions in HSK exams, should not be vague as to the language to which the translation can be made. 

    Back to the "What If" question used as a title for this article. Some years ago, while I was living in Toronto, I attended an interesting presentation by Matt Murrie, entitled called "What if our socks didn't match?!", dated April 2013.

    Following are screen shots from the LinkedIn comments with Khanji School.